The Occasional Jam No. 24

No. 24 strategy

Getting Better at Ghost

7 min read

Ghost deals you letters you can always win from and an opponent that never slips. The win is there before your first letter goes down, and a little counting tells you how long a word to look for.

It assumes you know the rules. If you don't, the how-to has them, with an example animation. Testing it, I wrote that the game "does feel fair, but it feels a bit guess-y." The opponent is the fair half: it hides nothing and plays the same way for everyone. The first letter is the guess-y half, since it can look like a coin toss. Some arithmetic shrinks that, and all of it below is checked against real rounds, each one solved in full.

What the score rewards

A won round pays 25 however it went. Everything else pays for how you won it, and added up, the how is worth more than the win.

The most one round pays before rare words. The win itself is under half of it.
The most one round pays before rare words. The win itself is under half of it.
ItemValue (points)
Winning the round25 points
Winning at Par15 points
The richest word15 points
Winning first try10 points

The two first-try bonuses of 10 and the 20 for doing it in both rounds come to 40 a day, more than full marks for the word in both rounds. A letter over Par costs 5. A round's first lost attempt costs 3, plus the 10 for a first try, plus the 20 if the other round was clean.

Win both rounds on the first try, nothing taken back, at Par, and the day is a Wow whatever words the opponent finished.

Now lose one attempt in each round and play everything else the same. On more than four days in five, those two wins fell to Cat. There's no clock, so the cheapest protection for the first try is time. Think before the first letter of each round, since most first letters lose.

Your letters tell you how long the word is

Par counts only your letters, and you don't see it while you play: the round's card says it once the round is over, as "won in 2 · Par 2". What it measures still helps before then. Each of your letters gets an answer, and in a win it's the opponent's answer that finishes the word, so the number of letters you play fixes how long the word at the end will be.

A win adds twice your letters to the letters you were dealt. Three letters won in one end on a five-letter word, and three won in two end on a seven-letter one. That held in every round I solved: the fastest win always ended on a word of exactly that length. So look for the words two letters longer than the deal first, and only then the ones four longer.

Round one: HAV, Par 1

HAVE       a word already: you lose
HAVING     3 letters away: ends on your G
HAVDALAH   5 letters away: ends on your H
HAVOC      2 letters away: ends on the opponent's C
HAVARTI    4 letters away: ends on the opponent's I
O wins at Par. A wins too, a letter over, through a rarer word.
Five letters were live. Only the words an even number of letters away end on the opponent.

A win in one letter on three dealt means a five-letter word, so you're looking for a fourth letter after which every way on is a five-letter word the opponent has to finish. HAVO can only become HAVOC, so O wins. Knowing the length to look for makes that a short search.

Your first letter

First letters round one allows, on average
10
Counted with the game's own solver.
Finished a word on the spot
25%
Won against the opponent's best play
32%

Only about a third of first letters won, and a quarter finished a word right away. The gray keys only rule out letters that lead to no word at all. A letter that finishes a word does lead to one, so it stays lit, and HAVE at HAV is exactly that: a live key you lose on.

So the first habit is the dull one. Before you tap, check that the line plus your letter isn't already a word of four letters or more. Then count. A word an even number of letters away from the board ends on the opponent's letter, and an odd number ends on yours.

The catch is that the opponent picks half the letters, and it picks them to leave you a word to finish. A letter is only good if every answer the opponent can give still leaves you a way through. The easy case is a letter that leaves only one word possible, because then nobody has a choice and the count decides.

A letter is only as good as the opponent's best answer to it.

Letters with one word behind them are common. On more than four days in five, round one had a winning first letter that left a single word possible, an even number of letters away. On about two in five of those days it was a word the game calls everyday or uncommon, like HAVOC. On the rest it was something rarer, which is where the next section starts.

Rare words are weapons

In round one the opponent steers by everyday words, but every real word counts, for both of you.

If you know the rarer word, use it. A at HAV leads nowhere but HAVARTI, four letters away, so the opponent finishes it. It takes two of your letters, one over Par, and still scores 3 more than HAVOC, because the card pays extra for a word it calls unheard of.

On more than half the days, some first letter in round one won only through rarer words, and usually two or more did. About one in four of those letters won in fewer letters than Par. Winning under Par pays the same as winning at it, but the rarer word pays more than an everyday one.

Take the fastest win unless you can see the rarer word all the way to its last letter.

The card at the end of a round names the richest word the round allowed, and playing for it from the start is mostly not worth it. In about seven rounds in ten it was in reach at Par anyway. On the rest, playing for it perfectly would have added a median of 4 points, and on one of them it would have lost 4. A single lost attempt on the way costs 13, more than the chase added on any of those rounds.

The twist

Round two deals three letters, and from then on both of you can add to either end. The dealt letters stop being the start of a word and become a piece of one, which is much harder to see. The count still gives the length: three letters, plus two for each of yours.

Fewer first moves win here. A twist allows about 19 live first moves on average, counting a letter on each end as its own move, and a little under one in four of them win. More than half of the wins are on the left end, though the board starts you on the right, so check the front before you settle on the back.

One twist dealt REQ. Seven moves were live, six of them on the left, and all three that won were on the left: F, O, and P. The one move on the right lost.

Don't expect to know the word that ends a twist. On nearly three twists in four, the best word a Par win could force was one the game calls unheard of.

The card pays extra for an unheard-of word whether you knew it or not, so in the twist, count letters and ends rather than hunting for a word you recognize. The count works the same as in round one: a word an even number of letters away from the board ends on the opponent.

When an attempt goes wrong

A lost attempt shows you where you went wrong. The board rewinds to the last spot you could still win from, so when it says "Really lost 2 moves back", the letter that finished the word wasn't the mistake. The one you played at the spot it rewound to was.

What lost attempts cost in one round

1st   3, and the 10 for a first try
2nd   6 more
3rd   9 more
4th   12 more
5th   GHOST is spelled, and the round scores nothing
The day's first lost attempt also costs the 20 for winning both rounds first try.
Taken from the bonuses, never from the 25 a win pays.

Take it back costs the first-try bonus just as a loss does, on top of its 2 points, so it's there for a mistap. I'm stuck takes a second tap, and with the way out it shows the word that way forces.

On points, I'm stuck never beats one more try. A win after four lost attempts still banks its 25, and a fifth loss scores the same nothing that skipping does. Press it when you'd rather see the answer than keep going, which is a fine reason. Either way, the round's card names the way out and the word it forces.

One note about the scoring tiers. The cuts for Jam, Cat, and Wow were set by hand, before there was real play to tune them against. If one feels wrong, that's my number and not your play.

Sources

  1. Ghost's own solver and scorer, run over released days Each round solved in full, so every share here comes from an exact count, rounded to a plain fraction. The richest-word comparison assumes perfect play either way. The scoring tier sentences apply the scoring tier cuts to each day's best word a Par win could force.