The Occasional Jam No. 08

No. 08 strategy

Getting Better at Colors

7 min read

Colors gives you three sliders and asks for a color three ways a day. Measured on days the game has really dealt, the hue is the slider that costs the most when it's off, so it's the one to get right first.

It assumes you know the rules. If you don't, the how-to has them, with an example animation. Everything below comes from two places: the scoring code, and a long run of the game's real days, every round put back through the game's own scorer. None of it comes from watching anyone play. The figures are what the scorer pays.

What the score rewards

Each lock-in shows two numbers, match and points. Match is how close your color is to the answer, by CIEDE2000, the color-science formula for how different two colors look to a person. Colors counts a gap of 60 on it as no match at all. of how different two colors look. Points come from match, but not one for one.

What a round pays at each match. Nothing until 40%, and the first gains above it pay the most.
What a round pays at each match. Nothing until 40%, and the first gains above it pay the most.
ItemValue (points)
40% match0 points
50% match37 points
60% match55 points
70% match68 points
80% match80 points
90% match90 points
100% match100 points

Below 40% a round pays nothing, because even a badly wrong color shows about 40% match. Above it the curve is generous. Climbing from 40% to 60% is worth 55 points, and climbing from 80 to 100 is worth 20. Getting a round roughly right is the first job, and polish can wait.

Wow asks for every round to be a near match, and since points near the top track match almost one for one, the climb from Cat to Wow is the slow stretch.

Fix the hue first

The how-to says to nail the hue first, and the scorer agrees by a wide margin. To check, take every round of those days, leave two sliders exactly on the answer, move the third a tenth of its length away, and score the result with the game's own code.

One slider a tenth of its length off, the other two exact, averaged over every round of a long run of real days.
One slider a tenth of its length off, the other two exact, averaged over every round of a long run of real days.
ItemValue (points)
Hue off55 points
Lightness off88 points
Vividness off95 points

A tenth of the hue slider is 36 degrees, which is a big miss. The same distance costs about a quarter as much on lightness and a tenth as much on vividness. At a twentieth of the slider the hue still costs 20 points, against 6 and 2. It hurts most on strong colors: a twentieth off costs 25 points on answers with high vividness, and 10 on muted ones.

A hue a little off costs more than lightness and vividness a little off put together.

So put the hue in first, and tap rather than drag: a touch anywhere on a slider sets it right there. Then use the other two sliders as swatches. The vividness slider is painted in your hue at your lightness, and the lightness slider in your hue at your vividness, so once the hue is right you can tap the spot that looks like the color.

Miss on purpose

75% match, 74 points

Two real Glimpse answers, scored by the game's own code. The hue starts a twentieth of its slider off. Try the same distance on the other two sliders.

Each of those two sliders repaints when the other moves, so go round them twice. And ignore where the sliders start: every round opens on a color that would pay nothing if you locked it in untouched.

At the end of the day, each round's card says which way each slider missed, like "Hue a little off" or "a little too light." Across days, Track record says when your misses lean one way on a slider, and a steady "a little too dull" is worth correcting on purpose. A day you missed in the archive counts when you play it, so it's more practice and three more cards to read.

Glimpse: say it in three words

Glimpse shows the color for five seconds and then hides it, and the sliders only slide in once it's gone. Five seconds is enough to say three words to yourself, one per slider. Put the hue against the hue slider's own stops, which run red, yellow, green, cyan, blue, magenta, and red again, top to bottom.

So skip "pink" and say "magenta going red, strong, middling." The hue goes first in the sentence because it's the slider that costs the most to get wrong. When the sliders appear, dial them in the order you said them.

By heart: dial the logo, not the sign

By heart gives you a name and no swatch: a brand, a crayon, a team, a school, a character, or something you'd pass on the street. The answer is the color its maker publishes, or the one sources agree on when no maker does. That means the logo in the brand's own files, not a sun-faded sign or the version your phone screen showed you.

When the name carries a color word, trust it for the hue and save your care for lightness and vividness, which the name doesn't give you. When the thing is one you've never seen, guess, lock in, and let the reveal teach you. Each answer on the round cards links to its page on ColorHexa, with its hue angle, saturation, and lightness: the three sliders, in numbers.

Blend: paint mixes darker than you think

Blend shows two paint swatches and asks what they make. It mixes the way paint does, not the way light does, so blue and yellow make a green, as they would in a paint box. White and black are paints too, so a pair with one of them asks for a tint or a shade of the other. On real days, paint mostly pulls one way: darker and duller.

Blends darker than the average of their two paints
7 in 8
By how light each looks.
Blends less vivid than the average of their two paints
Nearly 9 in 10
On the vividness slider.
Points for the halfway color on a blue and an orange
31
Out of 100, every time that pair was dealt.

So find the hue between the two paints, then pull lightness and vividness down from where halfway would put them. Paints from opposite sides of the hue slider fight hardest. A blue and an orange make a dark, muddy color.

Complement: build the shown color first

Complement shows a color and asks for its opposite. Dial the shown color first, matching the swatch above the board, then move only the hue, half the slider, toward whichever end has room.

On a keyboard this can be exact. An arrow moves a slider one step, Shift and an arrow move it ten, and Home and End jump to its ends, so eighteen Shift presses turn the hue halfway round. The trap is doing it by eye, which keeps how light and how strong the color looks. That kind of opposite averages 45 points on real Complements and pays nothing on one in five.

An opposite on the sliders can look much lighter or darker than the color it came from. On real Complements the two sit 28 apart on average in how light they look, on a lightness scale of 0 to 100. The rule follows the sliders on purpose, so a yellow's opposite is a blue that looks far darker, and the answer is that blue.

Chameleon: split the difference

Chameleon shows one small chip on two backgrounds. Both chips are the same color, and the backgrounds make them look like two. A background pushes a color away from itself, so on a light one the chip looks darker and on a dark one it looks lighter. The chip's hue drifts away from the background's hue in the same way.

In about three Chameleons out of four, one background is lighter than the chip and the other darker, judged by how light each looks. So the two chips lie in opposite directions, and the true color sits between them. Dial a color halfway between your two impressions, on lightness and on hue.

When you're torn, aim for the middle

The curve bends, and that matters on any round you're unsure of: a sure thing beats a gamble that averages the same. Take a round you're sure lands at 70%, against a coin flip between a perfect match and a 40% one. Both average 70% match, and they don't pay the same.

The sure 70% pays 68 points. The coin flip pays 50, because the perfect half pays 100 and the other half pays nothing.

So when you're torn between two lightnesses, or two hues, pick the point between them rather than betting on one. The middle pays something whichever one was right. A bet pays everything or, when the other one was right and far enough away, nothing.

Then take your time. Glimpse's five seconds are the only timer in the game, and lock in is final, so the time to be careful is before the tap. Look away from the board, look back, and check each slider once more. Before the last round, the scale at the top shows your points and the number the next scoring tier needs, so you'll know whether the third round decides it. That shouldn't change how you play it, because every round pays for closeness and nothing else.

For what it's worth, I do great on Glimpse, By heart, and Chameleon, and not as well on Complement or Blend. That's odd to me, because those two seem the most formulaic. I have a bad intuition there, and a good feel for things I've literally seen before.

And one note about the scoring tiers. The cuts for Jam, Cat, and Wow were set by hand, before there was real play to tune them against. If one feels wrong, that's my number and not your play.

Sources

  1. The game's own scorer Match, the 40% floor, and the curve above it are the board's code, which counts a CIEDE2000 distance of 60 as no match at all. Every figure here was scored with those same functions, not a copy of them.
  2. A run of the game's real days Every round of a long run of days the game actually dealt, each scored with the functions above.
  3. One slider off Each round's answer as whole numbers on the three sliders, two left exact and the third moved the same share of its length up and down, averaged over both directions and every round. High vividness means 60 or more on its slider, muted means under 35.
  4. How light a color looks CIELAB lightness (L*), from the culori library the game already uses to score.
  5. The opposite by eye The shown color turned halfway round in CIE LCh, which keeps how light and how strong it looks, then scored against the game's own answer.
  6. The halfway color The even average of the two paint swatches' red, green, and blue values.
  7. ColorHexa Where each answer on the round cards links.