No. 19 strategy
Getting Better at Thin Ice
Thin Ice shows you the whole pond before the first move and never runs a clock, so getting across at par starts before you press anything: read the pond, and work back from the checkers.
It assumes you know the rules. If you don't, the how-to has them, with an example animation. The figures below come from a solver that plays by the game's own rules. It works through daily ponds one at a time, finds every perfect crossing, and tests every move open along the way. They're exact counts, apart from one marked as a floor, and the sources at the end say what was run.
What the score rewards
Only a move that moves the disc counts. Walking into open water, a stone, or the edge does nothing and costs nothing. And because the scoring tiers below Wow are measured as a share of par, a bigger pond allows more extra moves for the same scoring tier.
Extra moves come from exactly two places, and the line under your crossing at the end names both.
The line under a finished crossing
No clock, so look first
Thin Ice has no clock, so thinking is free and pressing isn't. That settles the best first move when you have no idea where to go: no move. Read the board until you have a reason.
The first press is a real decision more often than not. On about seven days in ten, more than one first move was open and exactly one of them kept a perfect crossing possible. On three days in four, at least one open first move could never reach the checkers at all, and the game wouldn't say so yet.
So before the first press, find three things: the checkers and its way in, the tiles with only two ways in and out, and the striped bars of polished ice. A day you missed in the archive is a fresh pond to practice that read on.
Work back from the checkers
The crossing's last move has to come from one of the tiles around the checkers, and often there's only one. On about one day in four the checkers had a single open neighbor, which fixed the last two tiles before the first press.
On four days in five, every perfect crossing came in to the checkers through the same tile. Corners make it plain. With stone beside a checkers in the corner, the only way in is along the other edge, and if that tile is polished ice, every perfect crossing ends with a slide over it. The pond pictured in Meet Thin Ice is built exactly that way.
The practice pond below is small enough to try here. Its checkers sits between two stones on the left edge, so it can only be reached from the tile to its right. Work out where that tile must be entered from before you move.
Par 17. Break every tile, then end on the checkers.
Most moves aren't choices
Along a perfect crossing, half the positions offer only one move. Most of the rest offer a choice in which exactly one move keeps the crossing perfect. Real forks, where two different moves both still reach par, came up at about one position in twenty.
That's what the how-to's tip about corridors means in practice. A tile with only two open neighbors, about one tile in five, has to be entered through one and left through the other, unless you start or finish on it. Link those in your head first, and you'll only have the open middle left to think about.
Polished ice is never a place to stand. A perfect crossing slides over every striped tile without spending a move on it, so par is the number of tiles to break, less one for the tile you start on, less one for every striped tile. That held on every pond the solver checked. A slide stops on the first plain tile past the stripes, or on the stripes themselves if a stone or the edge comes first, and that second kind is the extra move. You can see which it will be before you take it.
Wrong turns keep quiet
- Perfect crossings on a typical day
- 2
- The median. About one day in three had exactly one.
- Wrong moves that leave no crossing at all
- 97%
- Counting every move that steps off a perfect crossing.
- Of those, the game lets you keep playing
- 93%
- It stops a run only once the run has actually ended.
Of the wrong moves open along perfect crossings, 97% left no crossing at all, so a wrong turn in Thin Ice is almost never a small one. The other 3% could still be finished, but only by stopping on polished ice somewhere, which is an extra move of its own.
The game rarely says so at once. Of those fatal wrong moves, 93% left the run going. On the 8×8 days, the median one left room for at least 25 more moves before the run had to end, a floor because the search stopped early on the longest walks.
There's one check you can make by eye after every press, and it catches about half of them on the spot. Every tile needs two ways: one in and one out. If any tile other than the checkers is down to one unbroken neighbor, counting the tile the disc is on, it can be entered but never left, and the run is already over.
Take Back, Restart, and guessing
When a run is dead, how you back out of it decides what it costs. A Take Back adds one extra move. A Restart adds every move the run made: it's the same as taking back every move of the run, and only saves you the taps. So taking back to the mistake never costs more than restarting, and the two cost the same only when the mistake was your first move.
When a run dies, stop, find the move that broke the pond, and take back to just before it. Every press you made on dead ice is one more to take back, which is why the one-way check is worth doing after every move, not only when you feel stuck.
Sometimes a guess is the only way on, and that's fine if it's cheap. Every probe costs at least one extra move, since the press counts and undoing it doesn't refund it. So guess as late as you can, after the checkers, the corridors, and the bars have narrowed things down, and check for one-way tiles after every press until the guess proves itself.
Where I go wrong: sometimes I get hasty toward the end and make a silly mistake that costs me the Wow. And every now and then I rush in too quickly and get pretty far before I realize I blundered early, which hurts, and reminds me of that part of my personality.
And one note about the scoring tiers. The cuts for Jam, Cat, and Wow were set by hand, before there was real play to tune them against. If one feels wrong, that's my number and not your play.
Sources
- Released Thin Ice days Read as published and checked byte for byte against the generator that made them.
- A solver run for this post on the game's own rules It plays with the same engine as the game, lists every perfect crossing of every day, and tests every move open along them. Every count in the post is exhaustive, none sampled. The one floor, how long a dead run on an 8×8 can go on, comes from a longest-walk search capped for each wrong move, so a capped walk counts as shorter than it is.
- The game's scoring code Where an extra move is defined as a move thrown away by Take Back or Restart, or a stop on polished ice, and where the scoring tiers are set as shares of par.
- The practice pond A 5×5 pond from the game's practice generator, the daily's own mix of stones and polished ice, at a size the daily doesn't use. Not a daily.